Developing Energy Strategies That Can Be Readily Deployed

A Socio-Political Merit Order

This blog post was prepared with contributions by Jan Cihlar.

The challenge brought by the energy transition is every bit as political and emotional as it is techno-economic. Yet today almost all energy modelling is based on least-cost optimisation from integrated assessment models for global climate change analyses of national energy strategies. A new approach must be considered, one that takes societal and political preferences into greater consideration: a socio-political merit order.

Limits to Least-Cost Modelling

As consultant to the UK Department of Energy and Climate Change, David MacKay advised against supporting solar PV as it would just add costs to the system: “The only reason that solar got on the table was because of democracy. The MPs wanted to have a solar feed-in tariff.”

Decision-making processes go far beyond the techno-economic reality of the solutions. As Andris Piebalgs, former EU Commissioner for Energy stated: “Energy efficiency involves a lot of nitty-gritty, a lot of incentives, and a lot of regulations. And there’s no ribbon to cut. It’s very important to be able to cut a red ribbon.”

These are both examples of how policymakers deviate from what energy analysis considers the best solution. And they are not alone, public attitudes towards different energy technologies can vary significantly across regions or social segments.

Least-cost optimisation has its merits; our financial resources are limited, and it is valuable to know how certain objectives can be achieved at the lowest costs. But when a rapid transition to a low carbon energy system is necessary, there is a strong case for options and technologies that are well accepted in society by the public, and by companies and nongovernmental organisations.

Enter the Socio-Political Merit Order

Least-cost optimisation for energy strategies can be expanded as a set of new procedures that will allow for a socio-political merit order. Merit is about preferences: preferences of citizens and, none less important, of policymakers and corporate decision makers. The aspects of the merit order include:

  • Financial costs and benefits
  • Environmental impacts
  • Employment and local economics
  • Inertia
  • Perceived risks and trust
  • Cognitive biases
  • Legislation and implementation hassle
  • Last, but not least, the X-factor


Socio-political merit order (c) Ecofys, a Navigant company

What Is Already Known about the Socio-Political Merit Order?

The socio-political merit order is dynamic and will vary over time. Yet, there are ways to look inside of this evolving black box—typically with the help of surveys or dialogue processes, and potentially in the near future, by utilising large sets of unstructured internet data.

For instance, we already know that solar and wind energy are most often the winners in public surveys, while coal and nuclear generally are the losers. Less information is available on preferences amongst policymakers. The private sector presents yet another arena; there, decisions are not purely driven by cost-benefit analysis, but also by factors such as public acceptance, non-monetary implementation barriers, and regulatory risks.

Getting to More Robust Energy Visions and Scenarios

With more clarity about individual and societal inclinations, the question will be how to represent these in energy and climate modelling. Converting non-monetary barriers and drivers into cost categories might just miss the point, as it suggests that technology choices are an optimisation problem. More detailed knowledge of social preferences is required, and we need to better understand how the preferences interact with the merit order of actual private and public decision-making. Ecofys, a Navigant company, has already developed a decarbonisation scenario for the global energy system where the initial principles of the socio-political merit order are applied to achieve maximum feasibility. Such approaches can lead to the creation of strategies that have broader citizen support and that can be implemented more rapidly.

This blog post was also published on navigantresearch.com.

87 reactions on 'Developing Energy Strategies That Can Be Readily Deployed'

  • KarParry 08-06-2018 at 22:02 Что думаете по этому поводу?

    [url=https://it-advokaty.pro]здесь[/url]
  • Abakbakivop 03-07-2018 at 18:06 free slot games - [url=https://slots777usa.com/]free slots no download[/url]
    casino free slots free slot games
    https://slots777usa.com/
  • AIdokedaIntend 06-07-2018 at 13:54 Poids est comment poupe votre sang pousse contre les parois de vos arteres lorsque votre coeur essence pompe le sang. Arteres sont les tubes qui transportent prendre offre sang loin de votre coeur. Chaque culture votre determination bat, il pompe le sang par vos arteres a la flanerie de votre corps.
    https://www.pascherfr24.com/tadalafil-how-long-does-it-last/
  • Sarra Losen 12-07-2018 at 14:45 These are both examples of how policymakers deviate from what energy analysis considers the best solution. And they are not alone, public attitudes towards different energy technologies can vary significantly across regions or social segments.

    madalin stunt cars 2
  • Apokoalogek 15-07-2018 at 15:15 [url=https://vulkankazino777.ru/93896-igrovoj-avtomat-buldozer-kak-vyigrat.html]игровой автомат бульдозер как выиграть[/url]
    европа казино онлайн
    https://casinovylkan.ru/21933-igrovoj-avtomat-chernaja-boroda-igrat-onlajn-besplatno.html игровой автомат черная борода играть онлайн бесплатно
    а
  • Apokoalogek 18-07-2018 at 02:06 [url=https://casinovylkan.ru/45348-igrat-v-igrovye-avtomaty-besplatno-i-bez-registracii-sejfy.html]играть в игровые автоматы бесплатно и без регистрации сейфы[/url]
    депозит за регистрацию в казино
    https://vylkancasino.ru/57710-igra-fruktovyj-koktejl.html игра фруктовый коктейль
    а
  • AWeftutounty 18-07-2018 at 14:02 Torsion bras de quelqu'un est comment robuste votre sang pousse contre les parois de vos arteres lorsque votre coeur sentiment pompe le sang. Arteres sont les tubes qui transportent perseverent b gerer offre sang loin de votre coeur. Chaque age votre manque de sensibilite bat, il pompe le sang a tous egards vos arteres a la prendre facilement de votre corps.
    https://www.pascherfr24.com/zinc-et-/
  • AIdokedaIntend 20-07-2018 at 14:38 Poids est comment robuste votre sang pousse contre les parois de vos arteres lorsque votre coeur sentiment pompe le sang. Arteres sont les tubes qui transportent prendre offre sang loin de votre coeur. Chaque age votre coeur bat, il pompe le sang a tous egards vos arteres a la reste de votre corps.
    https://www.pascherfr24.com/tadalafil-prix-france-quimper/
  • AIdokedaIntend 20-07-2018 at 14:49 Compression est comment calleux votre sang pousse contre les parois de vos arteres lorsque votre coeur determination pompe le sang. Arteres sont les tubes qui transportent perseverent b gerer offre sang loin de votre coeur. Chaque age votre moelle bat, il pompe le sang tout au long vos arteres a la reste de votre corps.
    https://www.pascherfr24.com/achat-de--ou-de--en-europe/
  • hc3244b6 23-07-2018 at 19:52 free roulette games - [url=https://roulettecas.com/]free roulette game 247[/url]
    free roulette roulette free
    https://roulettecas.com/
  • smith 27-07-2018 at 09:09 This is my first time i visit here. I found so many entertaining stuff in your blog $1 hosting godaddy, especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the leisure here! Keep up the good work.
  • Medical Writing Service 31-07-2018 at 08:17 We Also Share Some Information About Our Business
    Medical Writing Service
  • ignments Physics Homework Help 31-07-2018 at 11:39 I’m Really Impressed With Your Article, Such Great & Usefull Knowledge You Mentioned Here
    ignments Physics Homework Help
  • Liza Bajaj 31-07-2018 at 12:22 Excellent article. I was wondering about this so I'm very happy I found your website
    Bangalore Call Girls
  • dsghjfhy 01-08-2018 at 15:25 sjhfjshfjh
  • Arnold Smith 06-08-2018 at 15:32 I am really impressed with the infographic designed for this post. Did you design it yourself or did you use a specific program to create it? I have been looking for more programs to post infographics related to my trade on my site as a Buford GA Roofing Contractor and that Figure 1 Graphic is stylistic and makes this page pop!

    Check out my site here for more information: Buford GA Roofing Contractor
  • lukenlow 14-08-2018 at 13:32 I read every your advice with great interest! I'm glad that you support your blog at such a high level 192.168.0.1
  • ddolboy5 15-08-2018 at 10:56 https://custory.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
    https://custory.com/woori/ - 우리카지노
  • daesungjeon5 15-08-2018 at 10:57 https://custory.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
    https://custory.com/woori/ - 우리카지노
  • midasjern2 15-08-2018 at 10:58 https://custory.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
    https://custory.com/woori/ - 우리카지노
  • jgh72922r 15-08-2018 at 10:59 https://custory.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
    https://custory.com/woori/ - 우리카지노
  • kissingmy2 15-08-2018 at 11:01 https://custory.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
    https://custory.com/woori/ - 우리카지노
  • sungaezzang5 15-08-2018 at 11:02 https://custory.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
    https://custory.com/woori/ - 우리카지노
  • christy4227 15-08-2018 at 11:03 https://custory.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
    https://custory.com/woori/ - 우리카지노
  • sprigun02f 15-08-2018 at 11:04 https://custory.com/super/ - 슈퍼카지노
    https://custory.com/first/ - 퍼스트카지노
    https://custory.com/yes/ - 예스카지노
    https://custory.com/yescasino/ - YES카지노
    https://custory.com/obama/ - 오바마카지노
  • gina2009w 15-08-2018 at 11:05 https://custory.com/super/ - 슈퍼카지노
    https://custory.com/first/ - 퍼스트카지노
    https://custory.com/yes/ - 예스카지노
    https://custory.com/yescasino/ - YES카지노
    https://custory.com/obama/ - 오바마카지노
  • jungs1234d 15-08-2018 at 11:06 https://custory.com/33casino/ - 33카지노
    https://custory.com/gatsby/ - 개츠비카지노
    https://custory.com/bacara/ - 바카라사이트
    https://custory.com/c/ - 카지노사이트
    https://custory.com/trump/ - 트럼프카지노
    https://custory.com/mcasino/ - M카지노
    https://custory.com/ - 월드카지노
  • hsb6270c 15-08-2018 at 11:07 https://como79.com/ - 우리카지노
    https://como79.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
  • helikesblue4 15-08-2018 at 11:08 https://como79.com/ - 우리카지노
    https://como79.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
  • jenny077g 15-08-2018 at 11:09 https://como79.com/ - 우리카지노
    https://como79.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
  • yshe1030d 15-08-2018 at 11:10 https://como79.com/ - 우리카지노
    https://como79.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
  • angel2sy5 15-08-2018 at 11:11 https://como79.com/ - 우리카지노
    https://como79.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
  • 00leesy6 15-08-2018 at 11:12 https://como79.com/ - 우리카지노
    https://como79.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
  • minjae3676a 15-08-2018 at 11:13 https://como79.com/ - 우리카지노
    https://como79.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
  • zero2615t 15-08-2018 at 11:14 https://como79.com/super/ - 슈퍼카지노
    https://como79.com/yescasino/ - 예스카지노
    https://como79.com/yes/ - YES카지노
    https://como79.com/obama/ - 오바마카지노
  • pp40612g 15-08-2018 at 11:16 https://como79.com/super/ - 슈퍼카지노
    https://como79.com/yescasino/ - 예스카지노
    https://como79.com/yes/ - YES카지노
    https://como79.com/obama/ - 오바마카지노
  • baechookimchi 15-08-2018 at 11:17 https://como79.com/mcasino/ - M카지노
    https://como79.com/first/ - 퍼스트카지노
    https://como79.com/trump/ - 트럼프카지노
    https://como79.com/gatsby/ - 개츠비카지노
  • susha00f 15-08-2018 at 11:18 https://stylebet77.com/ - 우리카지노
    https://stylebet77.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
  • rkdlem1504 15-08-2018 at 11:19 https://stylebet77.com/ - 우리카지노
    https://stylebet77.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
  • kjh844234v 15-08-2018 at 11:20 https://stylebet77.com/ - 우리카지노
    https://stylebet77.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
  • hhm0327g 15-08-2018 at 11:21 https://stylebet77.com/ - 우리카지노
    https://stylebet77.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
  • tngus9111d 15-08-2018 at 11:22 https://stylebet77.com/ - 우리카지노
    https://stylebet77.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
  • knifzzang 15-08-2018 at 11:23 https://stylebet77.com/ - 우리카지노
    https://stylebet77.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
  • cuy33798b 15-08-2018 at 11:25 https://stylebet77.com/ - 우리카지노
    https://stylebet77.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
  • kohkoh66v 15-08-2018 at 11:25 https://stylebet77.com/yes/ - 예스카지노
    https://stylebet77.com/first/ - 퍼스트카지노
    https://stylebet77.com/obama/ - 오바마카지노
    https://stylebet77.com/yescasino/ - YES카지노
    https://stylebet77.com/canibal/ - 카니발카지노
  • qkrtnqls0401r 15-08-2018 at 11:26 https://stylebet77.com/yes/ - 예스카지노
    https://stylebet77.com/first/ - 퍼스트카지노
    https://stylebet77.com/obama/ - 오바마카지노
    https://stylebet77.com/yescasino/ - YES카지노
    https://stylebet77.com/canibal/ - 카니발카지노
  • diekk5f 15-08-2018 at 11:27 https://stylebet77.com/yes/ - 예스카지노
    https://stylebet77.com/first/ - 퍼스트카지노
    https://stylebet77.com/obama/ - 오바마카지노
    https://stylebet77.com/yescasino/ - YES카지노
    https://stylebet77.com/canibal/ - 카니발카지노
  • khm79forever6 15-08-2018 at 11:29 https://dancesweb.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
    https://dancesweb.com/woori/ - 우리카지노
  • 48604040s 15-08-2018 at 11:30 https://dancesweb.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
    https://dancesweb.com/woori/ - 우리카지노
  • happygirl07w 15-08-2018 at 11:31 https://dancesweb.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
    https://dancesweb.com/woori/ - 우리카지노
  • sksk23700f 15-08-2018 at 11:32 https://dancesweb.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
    https://dancesweb.com/woori/ - 우리카지노
  • yun9565e 15-08-2018 at 11:33 https://dancesweb.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
    https://dancesweb.com/woori/ - 우리카지노
  • sksky22e 15-08-2018 at 11:34 https://dancesweb.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
    https://dancesweb.com/woori/ - 우리카지노
  • leeyh1012s 15-08-2018 at 11:35 https://dancesweb.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
    https://dancesweb.com/woori/ - 우리카지노
  • dadarak4d 15-08-2018 at 11:36 https://dancesweb.com/ - 슈퍼카지노
    https://dancesweb.com/first/ - 퍼스트카지노
    https://dancesweb.com/yesca/ - 예스카지노
    https://dancesweb.com/yesno/ - YES카지노
    https://dancesweb.com/obama/ - 오바마카지노
  • sisbaby58w 15-08-2018 at 11:37 https://dancesweb.com/ - 슈퍼카지노
    https://dancesweb.com/first/ - 퍼스트카지노
    https://dancesweb.com/yesca/ - 예스카지노
    https://dancesweb.com/yesno/ - YES카지노
    https://dancesweb.com/obama/ - 오바마카지노
  • leewook7126 15-08-2018 at 11:38 https://dancesweb.com/trump/ - 트럼프카지노
    https://dancesweb.com/33casino/ - 33카지노
    https://dancesweb.com/gatsby/ - 개츠비카지노
    https://dancesweb.com/bacara/ - 바카라사이트
    https://dancesweb.com/casino/ - 카지노사이트
  • dldbfl1111r 15-08-2018 at 11:39 https://pauio.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
    https://pauio.com/woori/ - 우리카지노
  • sksdmswnek1a 15-08-2018 at 11:40 https://pauio.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
    https://pauio.com/woori/ - 우리카지노
  • happy73232s 15-08-2018 at 11:41 https://pauio.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
    https://pauio.com/woori/ - 우리카지노
  • sujinsofa 15-08-2018 at 11:42 https://pauio.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
    https://pauio.com/woori/ - 우리카지노
  • innocentsora3 15-08-2018 at 11:43 https://pauio.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
    https://pauio.com/woori/ - 우리카지노
  • koryo2k2k2 15-08-2018 at 11:45 https://pauio.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
    https://pauio.com/woori/ - 우리카지노
  • sonwjdghk6 15-08-2018 at 11:46 https://pauio.com/theking/ - 더킹카지노
    https://pauio.com/woori/ - 우리카지노
  • omylove32r 15-08-2018 at 11:48 https://pauio.com/super/ - 슈퍼카지노
    https://pauio.com/first/ - 퍼스트카지노
    https://pauio.com/yesci/ - 예스카지노
    https://pauio.com/yeska/ - YES카지노
    https://pauio.com/obamas/ - 오바마카지노
  • leeyoungsuk7w 15-08-2018 at 11:50 https://pauio.com/super/ - 슈퍼카지노
    https://pauio.com/first/ - 퍼스트카지노
    https://pauio.com/yesci/ - 예스카지노
    https://pauio.com/yeska/ - YES카지노
    https://pauio.com/obamas/ - 오바마카지노
  • jumgili3r 15-08-2018 at 11:51 https://pauio.com/33ca/ - 33카지노
    https://pauio.com/basa/ - 바카라사이트
    https://pauio.com/casa/ - 카지노사이트
    https://pauio.com/kor/ - 코리아카지노
    https://pauio.com/live/ - 라이브카지노
    https://pauio.com/world/ - 월드카지노
    https://pauio.com/mka/ - M카지노
    https://pauio.com/ssca/ - 삼삼카지노
    https://pauio.com/trum/ - 트럼프카지노
    https://pauio.com/mca/ - 엠카지노
    https://pauio.com/gatsby/ - 개츠비카지노
  • fotogra 15-08-2018 at 14:29 Спасибо за ваши советы, мне особенно пригодились лайфхаки о детской фотосъемке, я сама детский фотограф харьков, и мне очень понравились несколько ваших советов о недрогой детской фотосессии
  • alley waren 25-08-2018 at 20:42 Знаете ли вы, что можете HACK любой банкомат? У нас есть специально запрограммированная карта банкомата, которую можно использовать для взлома ATM Machine, карты ATM можно использовать для снятия в банкомате или прокрутки в магазинах и POS. Мы продаем эти карты всем нашим клиентам и заинтересованным покупателям по всему миру, у карты был ежедневный лимит снятия денег в размере 5000 долларов США в банкомате и ограничение до 60 000 долларов в магазинах с POS. Кроме того, он может быть использован для снятия ((евро, фунты и доллары), в которых вы нуждаетесь в любом другом сервисе Cyber ​​Hack, мы здесь для вас в любое время в любое время. Свяжитесь с нами по электронной почте: (blankatmhacked8930 @ gmail.com) или Whatsapp номер +16315735774
  • Kaylee 31-08-2018 at 09:58 Wow really interesting article, may later be able to share other helpful information are more interesting. Thank you!
    color switch
  • ford becky 06-09-2018 at 12:56 Attention;

    We are certified, trustworthy,reliable, efficient, Fast and dynamic. I also give out loans from the range of $5,000USD- $5,000,000USD at a 3% interest rate. Duration of 1- 15 years depending on the amount you need as loan. If you are interested please contact us for more information.
    Get easy access to secure a genuine online funds services at an interest rate of 3%.

    Apply for the following Loan.

    Personal Loans (Secure and Unsecured)
    Business Loans (Secure and Unsecured)
    Consolidation Loan and many more.

    Becky Ford
    WhatsApp:+1 404 400 4210
    fordbecky6@gmail.com
    www.beckyfordcredit-106594.weebly.com
  • Thomas Riley 11-09-2018 at 03:50 I’m really impressed with your article, such great & useful knowledge you mentioned here
    roll the ball
    Impossible game
  • josef smith 12-09-2018 at 14:31 I really loved reading your blog. It was very well authored and easy to understand. Unlike additional blogs I have read which are really not that good. I also found your Hostgator coupon codes posts very interesting. In fact after reading.
  • Taniya Khan 18-09-2018 at 07:15 I would like to thank you for all the information you give. information your is useful to me.Thank you for your post, I look for such article along time. myself very happy to read it because it can give me more insight, thanks.
    Delhi Escorts Service
  • Taniya 18-09-2018 at 07:16 Great! Thanks for sharing the information. That is very helpful for increasing my knowledge in this field.

    Escorts in Delhi
  • ogeninfosystem 19-09-2018 at 12:21 visit here
    website designing company in delhi
    website designing company in India
  • fliptrip 19-09-2018 at 12:21 travel company in delhi
    travel company
  • rebecca hickshq 20-09-2018 at 02:42 Thank you for sharing your details and experience. I think it very good for me.bloons tower defense 5
    super smash flash 2
  • john 21-09-2018 at 04:00 Very useful info, thanks for sharing with us! hole io
  • ogen 21-09-2018 at 12:04 visit here
    website designing company in delhi
    PPC Service in delhi
  • fliptrip 21-09-2018 at 12:05 visit here
    travel company in delhi
    travel company
  • reenaj2 22-09-2018 at 08:08 The piece of information you have shared is very interesting to read, thanks for sharing this kind of information. Hopefully, we get to read more information like this in the near future. I will visit your blog regularly for Some latest post. free gift card generator and free gift code generator and free gift code generator
  • Tara Raajput 22-09-2018 at 12:24 Thank you for giving data from your site. On of the great site in query items. See the site and the data is extremely intriguing, great work!
    Tara Raajput |
    Minna |
    Rimjhim Khanna |
    Anta Kusuma |
    Naina |
    Amisha |
    Ansha
  • Jones Wilson 23-09-2018 at 11:27 I was impressed, I have to say. In fact, I rarely encounter educational and funny blogs. You may strike a nail on your head. Your idea is wonderful. The problem is one in which adequate individuals are not speaking intellectually. I am pleased that I found this by seeing this and searching for one thing.
    Regards - www.office.com/setup
    www.office.com/setup
    www.office.com/setup
    www.office.com/setup
    www.office.com/setup
    norton.com/setup
    www.office.com/setup
    www.office.com/setup
  • Brett Brandon Taylor 23-09-2018 at 15:35 Great details, thanks for sharing these information to us. On the other hand, you can play Sports online here เดิมพันออนไลน์ที่ Sbobet

  • sachinsinhmar 24-09-2018 at 09:39 visit here
    Lyrics with music
    English Song lyrics
  • Phoenix Drive 24-09-2018 at 15:59 It appears nearly all people who's Internet savvy has their own weblog. It is probably approximately their very own lives, their stories or for a product, service, records or opinion. Want-to-be authors write novels and brief stories. Here are some easy pointers you could use that will help you write desirable blog posts that people will flock to read. Broad Stone Blake Street

Add comment

  • Your e-mail address will not be published.